Thursday, December 19, 2013

Forestar BULLETIN: Rehearing Report

 
First: Last night the Board of Directors held a rehearing on the Forestar application requesting 45,000 acre-feet of groundwater per year.  The Board has previously granted Forestar a permit for 12,000 acre-feet per year. 

The hearing was a well attended and well organized.  We thank the Board and staff for working with Environmental Stewardship and others to ensure that the public had an opportunity to hear the arguments of the Applicant (Forestar) and District Staff prior to making public comments.  We also thank the Board for allowing the public to pool its time so that we could make our arguments in a manner that could be heard and understood by the Board, the Applicant, and the Public. 

At the conclusion of the hearing, the Board adjourned the hearing but did not take action on the application. Our impression is that the Board will take some time to review the information provided at the hearing and make a written response to the Applicant early next year.  At that time the decision of the Board on the application will be final.  The board can, however, render its decision any time before that date.
   
Our message to the Board:   
Nothing has changed, STANDING STRONG!
We have your back.   
Second:  Environmental Stewardship (ES) presented a comprehensive review of previous information provided to the Board, responded to Forestar allegations, and presented new technical information on the application.  The new information was from the work of a certified hydrogeologist, George Rice, who was retained to review the technical studies conducted by the District (called Groundwater Availability Model (GAM) files), and extract new information on the impact of pumping large quantities of groundwater on surface waters, the Colorado River, and other aquifers.      
Rice's report concluded:  Forestar's pumping would:
  • Reduce hydraulic heads in the Hooper, Simsboro, Calvert Bluff, and Carrizo aquifers.
    • Where these aquifers are confined, the reduced heads would cause water levels in wells to decline
    • Where these aquifers are unconfined (i.e., recharge areas), the reduced heads would cause dewatering of portions of the aquifers.  
  • Reduce groundwater discharge to the Colorado River, thereby reding the amount of water flowing in the river.  
It should be noted that this information was not extracted and reported to the Board by the General Manager when he made his recommendations to approve 100% of the applicant's requested pumping.   
Click below for copies of documents:
Third:  As reported earlier, Forestar (USA) Real Estate Group, Inc. has requested a contested case hearing on Griffin Industries application for 224 acre-feet of water for industrial use within our District.  This will cost Griffin and the District a great deal in both time and money.  We believe this is a follow-up on the threat made by Forestar's attorney Edmond R. McCarthy when he said in his closing comments to the Board just moments before the motion for a rehearing was originally denied,  "if you don't give us our request[ed rehearing], this District has issued its last permit."       
************************  
Forestar's Contract with Hays County  
The driver behind litigation. 
Fourth: As reported earlier, Forestar has entered into a "water reservation" contract with Hays County Commissioners Court for 45,000 acre-feet of water per year, even though Forestar only has a permit for 12,000 acre-feet per year.  Hays County is paying Forestar $5 million over five years to reserve water Forestar does not have to sell, and Hays County is encouraging and funding what now becomes Forestar's and Hays County's hostile attempt to get the additional 33,000 acre-feet of water per year by SUING LOST PINES IN STATE DISTRICT COURT.   
************************
 To those who support our efforts and who support the Lost Pines Board: 
THANK YOU FOR SHOWING UP AND SHOW THE BOARD THAT YOU SUPPORT ITS CONSERVATIVE APPROACH  
TO PROTECTING THE GROUNDWATER UNDERNEATH  
BASTROP AND LEE COUNTIES.  
OUR JOB NOW IS TO DO ALL WE CAN TO BACK THE BOARD
DURING THE REHEARING & LAW SUITS THAT WILL FOLLOW.     
 **************************************
GROUNDWATER ACTION ALERT  
December 2013
Lost Pines Groundwater Conservation District Hearings
DrawdownDraw-down:  A Visual Perspective
PERMIT THIS NOT BANKRUPTCY
PRINT FLYER
What does "draw-down" resulting from groundwater pumping look like on a map?  As you may know, the Desired Future Conditions are established in terms of the draw-down, in feet, of aquifers in Bastrop and Lee counties and throughout the District. 

Recently, Environmental Stewardship obtained visual images based on the Groundwater Availability Model (GAM) used by the Lost Pines Groundwater Conservation District to evaluate the impact of proposed pumping from current permit applications on the Simsboro Aquifer.  Draw-down, measured in feet, is indicated on the contour lines of the maps below.  Click on Maps below to Enlarge

NOTICE:  Please keep in mind that the images below (except for Image 1) are for the PROPOSED permits ONLY (124,226 acre-feet/year) and DO NOT include EXISTING permits (45,365 acre-feet/year). 

GMA-DFC-Drawdown
Image 1.  PERMIT THIS - The draw-down, in feet, expected when the Adopted Desired Future Conditions (DFC) are met in Bastrop and Lee counties. The dark area in Burleson County is from Post Oak Savannah GCD pumping.  Click on Map to Enlarge
AllPermits100%Drawdown
Image 2.  NOT WATER BANKRUPTCY - The draw-down, in feet, expected if ALL current applications are approved and pumped to the maximum permitted.  Notice the red area in Lee county where draw-down is 1000 ft, and orange area in Bastrop County where draw-down is 750 ft.  Click on Map to Enlarge
Forestar100%
 Image 3.  WATER BANKRUPTCY - The majority of draw-down, in feet, in Lee County is from the proposed Forestar well field.  Click on Map to Enlarge

EndOp100%
Image 4.  WATER BANKRUPTCY - The majority of draw-down, in feet, in Bastrop County is from the proposed End Op well field, which is directly below Houston Toad habitat.  Click on Map to Enlarge
PERMIT THIS: 
If permitted at all, individual permits should first be reduced to levels actually supported by the application and then all permits reduced overall as necessary to an aggregate level that, including existing permits, protects the Adopted Desired Future Conditions.  In summary, if permitted at all, Forestar and End Op qualify for less than 5% of the water they are seeking.  In addition, the district needs to factor in the impact of existing permits before issuing any new permits. This has not been done. (See Image 1). 
Forestar25%
Image 5.  This image depicts Forestar pumping reduced to 25% of requested pumping volume but DOES NOT include existing permits.  Click on Map to Enlarge

EndOp25%
Image 6.  This image depicts End Op pumping reduced to 25% of requested pumping volume but DOES NOT include existing permits.  Click on Map to Enlarge
websiteblogNew Website and Blog
WebsiteHeaderLaGrangeWe are excited to announce that we have a new website and blog.  The site contains the same information that was on our old site, but now includes the ability to BLOG.  This means the site is MUCH MORE INTERACTIVE by allowing you, the reader, to make comments on specific pages and information posted.  We look forward to having a conversation with you about your interests and concerns. 

To visit our new website and blog click on this link.

Click here to link to our RSS Feed
 
If you find this information useful and informative, please forward it to a friend and invite them to join our e-News mailing list. 
                                                                             Forward to a Friend
Please DONATE NOW!

Be a Good Steward

Stay Informed

Be Involved


PayPalDonateButton
 
Join Our Mailing List
Forward to a Friend
Our Mission

NF Archery

Environmental Stewardship is a charitable nonprofit organization whose purposes are to meet current and future needs of the environment and its inhabitants by protecting and enhancing the earth's natural resources; to restore and sustain ecological services using scientific information; and to encourage public stewardship through environmental education and outreach. 

We are a Texas nonprofit 501(c) (3) charitable organization headquartered in Bastrop, Texas.  
Quick Links
Join Our Mailing List
Forward to a Friend



No comments:

Post a Comment